Broth Book 3

A new book by Sally Fallon Morell and Kaaya T. Daniel, PhD, CCN

In short, I would describe this book as a reference guide and cookbook for everything you ever wanted to know about broth and so, so much more.  It is available now via our Amazon affiliation. It is fairly comprehensive in its scope and clearly very well-researched. You will learn, in great detail, why and how to make this most nourishing food. The book includes inspirational testimonials about the healing power of broth weaved in throughout. I had the sense that I wanted to drink broth while I read the book, and was completely convinced that I need to make it more consistently. I aspire to return to having broth every day again, as has been my practice in the past. I was surprised to find that a book about broth proved to be a page turner for me. I found it to be incredibly well-written and a sincere pleasure to read. Dedicated to their grandmothers, Sally Fallon Morell and Kaayla T. Daniel have created a cookbook that can help us treat auto-immune disorders, infectious diseases, digestive problems and other chronic ailments. The book is divided into 3 parts, with an introduction:

  1. Basic Broth Science
  2. The Healing Power of Broth
  3. Recipes – more than half the book comprises of recipes that use broth and stock, some provided by community members

The section on Basic Broth Science covers the individual components in broth such as collagen, cartilage, bone, marrow, conditional protein powder, key amino acids and proteoglycans. We learn the definition, function and benefits of each component. We also learn about how broth can heal osteoarthritis. rheumatoid arthritis, scleroderma, psoriasis, wound healing, infectious disease, digestive disorders, cancer, mental health, be beneficial to sports and fitness and can serve to be anti-aging. The recipe section includes basic techniques, stock and broth recipes, blended and unblended soups, aspics, stews and stir-fries, various kinds of sauces, grains and legumes, broth for breakfast, tonics and broth on a large scale. Some of the highlights of what I learned:

  • Broth is a libido booster than can help men and women maintain love and lust into great old age.
  • Broth contains components with known anticarcinogenic activities, the most notable of which is cartilage. In other words, broth can help prevent and heal cancer.
  • It’s reputation as Jewish penicillin not-withstanding, Asians consume the most chicken soup today.
  • Bone marrow is not only highly nutritious, but takes much less energy to digest than plant food.
  • There are 29 distinct types of collagen that exist in animal tissues and it serves like glue to hold the body together.
  • Broth heals the gut primarily by feeding its cells the protein sugars known as glycosaminoglycans, or GAGs. Given that leaky gut syndrome is sometimes called the GAG defect, common sense suggests the glucosamine, chondroitin sulfate, and other GAGs found in broth could help the body rebuild the GAG layer.
  • There is no clear consensus about whether or not there is any difference between stock and broth. Amongst some chefs, stock isn’t meant to be eaten on its own; rather, stock serves as the basis for soups, sauces, and stews, and therefore should not be salted or highly seasoned. Broth is defined as “seasoned stock”, which can be eaten on its own, as a soup. In this book, the terms are used interchangeable. Both stock and broth are clear or semi clear liquid; soup is made by adding ingredients to stock or broth.
  • Perhaps the most significant article ever written on the value of gelatin and health came in 1937 when Dr. Frances Pottenger MD recited a long list of conditions that could be relieved by gelatin, including slow digestion, nervous digestion, vomiting, diarrhea, gas formation, and heartburn. He found it especially helpful for children with allergies and failure to thrive.

I could easily list another 25 points but, hope it will suffice to say that I believe that I learned something on every page of Nourishing Broth. The last point I mentioned was about gelatin, and I wanted to highlight the following section as we often talk about it in our Facebook forums.

Gelatinous Stock

The authors instruct us that the goal is gelatinous stock, stock that sets up as a solid gel if you put it in the fridge, so solid that you can turn the container over and the gel will stay in place. Broth that doesn’t gel is a common complaint. Following is a brief summary of the main reasons your stock doesn’t gel:

  1. Not the right kind of bones. You want bones that have a lots of cartilage. Also, one way to ensure plenty of gelatin is to include feet – chicken feet and heads for chicken broth and beef or calve’s feet for beef and veal stock. Pigs feet can be used in any stock to ensure an adequate gel.
  2. Not enough bones and too much water. When you make stock, the water should just cover the bones.
  3. The stock was heated to too high a temperature. Stock should be heated over medium heat until the liquid starts to roll, and then turned down to low heat so that the stock barely simmers.
  4. The stock didn’t cook long enough – or it cooked too long. You need to cook the stock long enough to extract the collagen, but not so long that the gelatin fibers break into short pieces. As a general rule, cook chicken or veal stocks for 4 to 6 hours and beef stock for a full day or overnight. Fish collagen will dissolve into the water at temperatures well below the boil and in as little as half hour. I noted, as I imagine some of you will, that this is less time than is recommended in Sally Fallon Morell’s book Nourishing Traditions, and will clarify this point with her and report back!

To answer a common question we receive in our community, the authors explain that if your broth hardly thickens at all, it is still worth consuming, as there will always be some gelatin in it, not to mention minerals and many other nutrients.


My twelve- and sixteen-year-olds fought a bad case of the flu with fevers never dropping below 101 and rising as high as 102.6. On the third day of this, I started giving them bone broth. That evening their fevers finally dropped below 100 and for the duration of the flu it never again went above 102. They both were completely better within a few days. The bone broth helped them to turn a corner, and I believe was the catalyst to their healing. If there is a next time, I will be giving it to them on the first day of an illness. —Charlotte Corbitt, Queen Creek, Arizona

I highly, highly recommend Nourishing Broth as another valuable contribution on how to nourish ourselves and our children. I found it to be both incredibly educational and inspirational. Bravo, Sally and Kaayla, whom I feel blessed to collaborate with as colleagues in the Weston A. Price Foundation. I think this book is worthy of a standing ovation. I am deeply appreciative to have it in my collection and anticipate that I will refer to it often. My experience of broth is summarized in the book itself: Broth improves the digestibility and assimilation of food, giving the body the critical message that it is deeply nourished, happy, and full.


Grand Central Publishing has offered me 3 copies of the book Nourishing Broth to have sent complimentary to randomly chosen individuals with a United States address who comment below before October 7. Please answer this question with at least 4 or 5 sentences to enter the giveaway:

What is your experience of nourishing broth?

[Giveaway results – Melissa K., Rachel and Maiken were randomly chosen to receive Nourishing Broth complimentary.]