Today, I’ve decided to post two entries from our Facebook archives since most of us are in need of supplemental food sources of Vitamin D at this time of year, as well as sources of nutrient dense foods to boost our immune system. Salmon roe, picture above, is a nutrient dense food for all of us – before conception, while pregnant, while nursing and yes, for babies who are eating solids … and then we may continue to be nourished by them long after we are of childbearing age! One of our mothers wrote, “My baby loves it, it’s the perfect finger food for babies just learning to eat. I cringe when I see babies eating O shaped cereal.” As was mentioned, what follows appeared originally on Facebook and you may find some comments of interest there.
The Nutritional Benefits of Fish Roe
Fish roe or fish eggs have been a sacred food across the globe since ancient times. In his writings, Dr. Weston A. Price detailed the great lengths the natives of the Andes went to carry dried fish roe from sea level back to their villages high in the mountains—sometimes hundreds of miles—to supply those of childbearing age with the nutrients needed to make the healthiest of babies. These nutrient- dense eggs are rich in vitamins A, D, and K2 (Activator X) along with zinc, iodine, and the brainbuilding fatty acid DHA, making them a powerful superfood for babies and adults alike. According to a recent Weston A. Price Foundation-funded analysis by UBE Laboratories, fish eggs contain 17,000 IU vitamin D per tablespoon!
The Eskimos consumed roe from salmon and other fish in large quantities, often daily. During the warm season, salmon roe was dried in the sun to preserve it for use throughout the year, especially for pregnant women. As one can imagine, there are many choices when it comes to fish roe. While most people associate fish eggs with caviar, technically, the only fish roe classified by this name comes from the prehistoric freshwater beluga sturgeon. All other varieties are simply fish eggs or roe, but they are usually prepared in the same way. The caviar process involves separating the fish eggs from the membrane by passing them through a sieve. The liquid is pressed off, and the eggs are mildly salted and sealed fresh in small tins, or they are canned and heat treated.
Salmon roe is one of the more accessible and generally better tasting fish roes available. In Japan, salmon roe—called ikura, borrowed from the Russian ikra—is used in making sushi, as is the sweet-tasting bright orange-red roe called tobikko that comes from flying fish, and that typically appears on California rolls in sushi restaurants. Note: most California rolls contain additive-filled imitation crab meat; simply request that the real crab be used.
Salted, processed “caviar,” whether fresh or canned, is delicious with finely chopped onions and sour cream. Put a dollop of creme fraiche or sour cream on a good quality cracker or crispy pancake, top with the fish eggs and finely chopped onions. Unprocessed roe comes fresh, frozen, smoked or dried. If you are a fisherman and find roe in your fish, be sure to scoop it out and eat it on the spot—or save and serve with toast and butter when you get home. Your fish monger may also have fresh fish roe. Unprocessed frozen fish eggs are available online at Vital Choice, one of our referral partners.
But, how do you eat them?!
Frozen eggs can be thawed and used as needed. Toss a few on the high-chair tray for baby; he will more often than not enjoy his “salty peas,” as Nina Planck, author of Real Food, calls them. Another easy way to incorporate fresh roe is to top a soft boiled, pasture-raised egg with a little scoop or try blending a dollop into your next salmon salad … or these deviled eggs with homemade mayo.
Dried fish roe is called for in the recipe below, and previously available here, but it does not appear to be on their product menu now. If folks know of an alternative, trusted source for dried fish roe, let us all know!
Smoked Salmon and Fish Roe Dip
1/2 cup chopped smoked salmon
2 tablespoons freshly squeezed organic lemon or lime juice
4 ounces cream cheese, preferably organic or homemade
2 tablespoons minced organic red onion or green onion
1 to 2 tablespoons dried fish roe
Salt and pepper to taste
In food processor, mix all ingredients until smooth. Store in an airtight container in refrigerator for up to 24 hours. One tablespoon of fish roe supplies 17,000 IU vitamin D. Combining fish roe with sour cream, crème fraîche or cream cheese supplies vitamins A, D and K2 all together; a dynamite sacred food combo!
The above text was inspired by Jen Allbritton’s article.
Nourished Kitchen recommends:
Serve roe on its own, paired with cucumbers, served with homemade crackers and freshly cultured sour cream. Alternatively, consider serving taramasalata – a traditional Greek dip featuring unrefined extra virgin olive oil and tarama – carp roe.
What follows in the next paragraph appeared originally on Facebook and you may find some comments of interest there.
This was one of Dr. Price’s most favorite photos. This lovely Peruvian girl with her round face lived high up in the Andes Mountains at 12,000 feet. She is holding some dried fish roe. He found that these cultures valued dried fish eggs, which they carried from the seashore to the high altitudes in their back backs. He asked the people why they went to such trouble to bring fish eggs high up in the mountains. The answer: “We need these fish eggs so we can have healthy babies.” It was the same reply he got in Alaska from the Eskimos when he asked them about their salmon roe.
Indigenous peoples knew instinctively what science has taught us—fish eggs contain many nutrients necessary for optimum reproduction, including vitamins A, D and K, minerals like zinc and iodine, and certain fats called DHA and EPA that are important for normal reproduction, especially the development of the brain and nervous system in babies. According to Dr. Price, fish roe is also an excellent source of the X Factor.
So how did they know?
How did populations separated by thousands of miles know that consumption of fish eggs ensured healthy babies? Dr. Price was in awe at the instinctual wisdom of so-called primitive peoples throughout the world. As Sally Fallon Morell says, “We do not have any answer to the question of how they knew. We’ve lost that instinctual knowledge. We need science to get us back to where these people were. Our mission statement at the Weston A. Price Foundation is the scientific validation of these traditional food ways. Unfortunately, science has been perverted; it has been bought up by the food industry and is not being used to validate the ways of nature.”
How do we get fish eggs today?
You can cure your own salmon roe with salt and sake at home. This is by far the freshest and most tasty version. If you can find fresh eggs, this is the way to go. Fresh eggs are available at the farmers market on Saturday in Larkspur for those in the San Francisco Bay Area. Here is a web site with photos to show you how to clean the membrane and cure the roe. It takes about 30 minutes or so at least the first few times:
[Updated] I now want to recommend Lummi for salmon roe after having tasted it last night. Although the package was frozen and the date is labeled 2009, the taste and quality was very good. The texture was a bit more gummy than the fresh version, which is very light and liquidy (inside) and does not have a fishy smell. Please note that Nourishing Our Children is not a referral partner for Lummi. My recommendation comes strictly from my own personal taste preference.
Up until now, I have been ordering and recommending Vital Choice’s salmon roe, however in comparison to Lummi’s, the Vital Choice brand tasted more salty and smelled very fishy and in comparison did not seem fresh at all. The texture was even more gummy than Lummi’s. Also, Lummi’s is more cost effective.
I will continue to recommend Vital Choice for their canned seafood — still the best sardines, mackerel and tuna I have ever had!
This photograph is reproduced by permission from the Price-Pottenger Nutrition Foundation. All rights reserved. Please reproduce only with their express written permission.
Yet, feel free to share this post with your circle!
32 Responses to Nutrient Dense Fish Roe
I noticed you don’t specify that only Wild Caught Salmon should be used. I’m fairly new to the world of nutrition, yet I have read terrible things about farmed Salmon and am now wondering what your stance on Farmed Salmon is.
Yes! Only wild caught salmon, for sure! The sources I linked to, and recommended, only offer wild caught but, I will amend the post to ensure clarification of this most important point. Thank you, Bonnie!
Fish eggs are delicious. I didn’t realize it was so nutritious too.
Yes! They are a powerhouse of nutrition … that and fermented cod liver oil: http://www.greenpasture.org/public/Home/index.cfm
[…] Nutrient Dense Fish Roe […]
I am reading Nutrition and Physical Degeneration by Dr. Weston A. Price with the Nutritional Wisdom Book Club and just read this today: “The eggs of the salmon are dried and stored as an important item of nutrition for both children and adults. They are also used to increase the fertility of the women. From a chemical standpoint they are one of the most nutritious foods I have found anywhere.”
He also writes that “These foods constitute a very important part of the nutrition of the small children after they are weaned. “
I was wondering if the fish eggs at a sushi restuarant are wild caught & therefore a good thing to recomend to my postpartum doula clients. They need some “quickie” options for nutrient dense foods since a brand new baby is pretty time consuming. Thanks for all the great info!
I would ask the restaurant about their source. Each one is different … some serve imitation crab meat!
[…] Fresh seafood, 2-4 times per week, particularly wild salmon, shellfish and fish eggs […]
At what age can a baby start eating the fish eggs? Is there any risk in terms of fish allergy?
Is this the specific product you recommended?
Still wondering about my questions above. Any thoughts?
Tara, didn’t realize your comment awaited a response until now. I think once you start solids, after you are past the first stages, you can introduce! http://www.cheeseslave.com/when-to-feed-baby-why-start-solids-at-4-to-6-months/ – in the comments both AnnMarie and one of her readers acknowledge fish eggs as a beneficial first food for babies.
Also, Tara – yes … that is the product I thought was fabulous!
I want to recommend ilovebluesea.com for salmon roe! I just ordered from them – wild from the pacific and packaged in a glass jar! I bought in bulk (they arrive frozen so are just stashed in my freezer) and it came out to about $13 a jar. I am really pleased.
I do have a question: is there such thing as too much roe for a 17 month old? Between us we could easily share a 4 oz jar every day. I’d say he would easily eat 1oz every day. We both are addicted! Is there any reason to limit consumption (other than cost of course)?
Jessica, I don’t think there is such a thing as too much! Some may very well argue in favor of rotation, however some traditional cultures that Dr. Price observed did eat a lot of the same kind of foods. From my perspective, no worries on the amount!
Interesting. With today’s problems with contamination of food, where would we get salmon eggs that don’t have mercury or chemicals in them? How would the upcoming release of genetically modified salmon (that can breed with wild trout and outcompete other wild varieties) affect our ability to safely consume it?
Hi! I just wanted to leave a comment here. I’m a 4th generation salmon fisherman… Well woman actually. I am also very concerned about the genetically modified salmon. My best advice is to look for the words “Wild Alaska Caught” we are one of the only clean/quality salmon fisheries left.
Where do you sell your products?
Any salmon roe?
Hi, I do believe this is a great site. I stumbledupon it ;)
I’m going to revisit once again since I bookmarked it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to guide other people.
[…] Source […]
Hi, I see the last comment was written on here some time ago, so hopefully you are still answering questions :) I ordered salmon roe from Vital Choice and it comes in 6 oz packages. Can I thaw the roe, separate it into smaller container and then refreeze it? How long does it last, thawed, in the fridge?
I am so sorry to only be seeing this comment now. I must have missed the notifications! I would contact Vital Choice directly for questions about their product.
I have a question I hope you can get to… I give my one year old fermented cod liver oil. Since they are both rich in Vitamins A and D and Dha, will it be too much for him? Thank you
Also wondering this!
I am so sorry to only be seeing this comment now. It depends on the quantity you offer, of course, however I would not have a concern about too much!
Please see this article: http://www.westonaprice.org/health-topics/abcs-of-nutrition/vitamin-a-saga/
Nice post!! Fish roe is very healthy. And, yes, we eat fish roe, too. Mostly, cheaper versions than salmon though – we normally you get them in the supermarket. My favourite recipe is that: http://leckerbiss.wordpress.com/2014/08/26/manga-salad-goes-with-or-without-sushi/
It can be used for all different kinds of roe.
I love cod roe, boild it in salty water until cook then let it cool and peel, slice and eat with mayonaise or in salads, you can add some raw to butter in a pan warm it up add salt and spread on toast or add some to scramble eggs, omlets,ect.
Hello! I know this post is older, but I have the same question as the ladies above, how long can you keep the thawed roe in the fridge? I’m not sure we would use it up at one sitting.
Hi Diana, just seeing this once. I am not sure how long you can keep in the fridge because I’ve never had it go bad. I imagine like most food, at least a week?!
[…] incorrect information has been published on multiple websites, all parroting the same number: Nourishing Our Children, Real Food Forager, The Coconut Mama, Holistic Squid and […]
A fishermen just gave us some salmon roe! As I read this – “defrost” – does that mean we just eat them raw?
And a second question please – most of the eggs are not loose, but attached to a membrane. Do you eat the membrane as well?